Scrum Master and Project Manager: Can you do both?

In the ever-evolving world of project management, professionals are sometimes faced with the challenge of combining agile methods such as Scrum with traditional approaches. The consideration of being both Scrum Master and Project Manager in one role is unfortunately not uncommon in practice, although this is certainly not recommended.

It is often financial reasons that lead to this dual role. This article examines the balance between these two roles and provides tips for those who are active in both roles when there is no other way: Is it possible to be a project manager and scrum master at the same time, and if so, how?

Project Manager and Scrum Master

Scrum Master and Project Manager: What are the responsibilities?

Let’s start by considering what the difference is between the two roles of Project Manager and Scrum Master. Let’s summarize the responsibilities.

Scrum Masters: The Scrum Master is responsible for implementing the Scrum principles in an agile development environment. The tasks include:

1. Facilitator: Facilitate the Scrum process and ensure that all meetings are effective.
2. Remove obstacles: Remove problems and obstacles for the development team to ensure a smooth workflow.
3. Coaching: Support the team in the application of Scrum and promote continuous improvement.
4. Promote communication: Facilitate communication within the team and with other stakeholders.

Project manager: The project manager is responsible for the holistic planning, implementation and monitoring of a project. The tasks include

1. Project planning: Creation and monitoring of a comprehensive project plan with clear objectives, resources and schedules.
2. Team leadership: Motivation of the team, conflict management and ensuring that goals are achieved.
3. Risk management: Identification, assessment and management of risks in the course of the project.
4. Budget responsibility: Monitoring and control of project finances.
5. Communication with stakeholders: Ensure clear communication with team members and other stakeholders.
6. Quality management: Monitoring of work performance and implementation of quality controls.
7. Project completion and evaluation: Completion of the project and evaluation to identify learning opportunities for future projects.

In summary, the Scrum Master is more focused on the agile methodology and the team, while the Project Manager has a broader responsibility for the overall project execution and stakeholder management.

Let’s go one step further: Can a project manager be a Scrum Master, or conversely, can a Scrum Master be a project manager?

Before we go deeper, a quick note: If you want to become a really good leader, a servant leader, I recommend the following video. It explains 21 scientifically based behaviors that distinguish mediocre from excellent leaders - feel free to take a look.

Play

Scrum Master and Project Manager

Can a Scrum Master be a project manager?

Basically, it is recommended to pursue the Scrum Master role full-time - as well as the project manager role. If both roles are performed at the same time, some work areas will definitely suffer. But if there is no other way, can a Scrum Master be a Project Manager?

If you simply do not want to hire an additional Scrum Master: It is theoretically possible to be both a Scrum Master and a Project Manager at the same time, but it is important to note that these roles have different focuses and responsibilities.

The Scrum Master focuses on the agile principles and supporting the team, while the Project Manager manages the comprehensive planning, implementation and monitoring of the entire project.

In smaller organizations or projects with limited resources, it may be more necessary for one person to take on both roles. In such cases, a clear delineation of tasks and efficient scheduling is crucial to ensure that the requirements of both positions can be met. This also requires a deep understanding of both methods and the ability to switch flexibly between the different approaches.

Let me give you some more concrete tips if you have to combine both roles - Scrum Master and Project Manager - in one person.

Scrum Master and Project Manager

Tips for Scrum Masters as project managers

Here are some tips for someone who wants to take on both roles - Scrum Master and Project Manager:

1. Prioritize team empowerment: As a Scrum Master, the focus is on promoting self-organization and team empowerment. This should take precedence in order to preserve agile principles. It is most likely that the “soft” factors in the team will be prioritized last - this should be actively counteracted.

2. Tackle conflicts proactively: If there are conflicts of interest between the two roles, be proactive in resolving them. Clarify uncertainties and work to ensure that both roles can be performed successfully.

3. Obtain team feedback: Seek regular feedback from team members to ensure you are performing the two roles in parallel in a constructive way.

4. Delegate, if possible: If the size of the project or team allows it, try to delegate tasks to spread the workload. This could increase efficiency and ensure that neither role is neglected.

5. Use tools and technologies: Use project management tools (such as Jira) and continuous improvement tools (such as Echometer) to make your work as a Scrum Master measurable. Automation can help to minimize the administrative effort.

6. Set priorities clearly: Identify clear priorities, especially when it comes to conflicts between the requirements of the agile methodology and traditional project management. Decide situationally which role takes priority in different phases of the project.

7. Practicing self-reflection: Take time for self-reflection to ensure that you critically evaluate your own performance in both roles. Identify areas where improvements can be made.

8. Seeking mentoring: Seek mentoring or exchanges with experienced people who may have performed similar dual roles. Sharing experiences can provide valuable insights.

9. Set boundaries: Avoid overworking by setting clear limits for working hours and availability. Burnout can be avoided if you make sure you schedule enough breaks.

10. Celebrate successes: Celebrate successes (personal and team), no matter how small. This helps to keep the team motivated and focus on positive results.

If you take all this into account, then a Project Manager can also be a Scrum Master or a Scrum Master can also be a Project Manager. Let’s slowly come to a conclusion with a tip for when you are both a Project Manager and a Scrum Master.

Scrum Master and Project Manager

A tool for the dual role

Do you want to ensure that your work as Scrum Master of your team bears measurable fruit? Echometer can help you with this. It was specially developed for teams that do not have a dedicated full-time Scrum Master.

Echometer is a digital tool that helps agile team leads with agile retrospectives and team Health Checks. Whether remote, hybrid or on-site: it makes team coaching measurable and professionalizes your work while saving you a lot of work. Just take a look at our website to find out more: www.echometerapp.com.

Your most important target variable at the beginning of your project is “trust.”

Christian Heidemeyer, Psychologist & Scrum Master

Scrum Master and Project Manager

Conclusion - Scrum Master and Project Manager

Although not generally recommended, the combination of scrum master and project manager theoretically also opens up opportunities for synergetic project management. Through clear role delineation, effective scheduling and consistent application of agile principles, project professionals can take on both positions and thus reap the benefits of both roles. Understanding the specific requirements and hard prioritization are key components for successful integration of both roles in the dynamic environment of project management.

Lastly, a reminder: If you would like to try out how it feels to further develop your team with our tool: You can start an agile retrospective without logging in below, in this case the “Keep, Stop, Start” workshop. 

Alternatively, simply forward our website to the responsible colleagues: www.echometerapp.com.